Inside the Scoring Sheet: What Commissioners Really Want to See

✅ Blog 4 of 7 in our Tender Review Series
Links to all 7 blogs in this series are at the bottom of this page.

If you’ve ever read a tender debrief that says “a good response, but not the highest scoring,” you’re not alone.

Many providers submit solid, compliant answers — but still fall short of top marks. The difference isn’t luck. It’s clarity, structure, and alignment with the scoring framework. That’s why some choose to work with a bid writer for domiciliary care or a bid writer for learning disability services to make sure their submissions inspire full confidence with commissioners.

🎯 What commissioners are really looking for

Behind every evaluation panel is one key goal: to identify the provider who gives them the most confidence.

That confidence comes from answers that:

  • ✅ Directly address every part of the question
  • ✅ Align with the specification and outcomes required
  • ✅ Demonstrate capability with clear, localised examples
  • ✅ Use active, confident language (no hedging!)
  • ✅ Show structure and logic throughout

Commissioners don’t want guesses. They want assurance.

🧩 The hidden scoring criteria

Most tenders come with a published scoring framework. But experienced reviewers know there’s more to it than what’s written.

Commissioners also reward:

  • 🔍 Clarity of explanation (no jargon)
  • 📚 Evidence of outcomes, not just intentions
  • 🛠️ Practical delivery plans, not vague ideas
  • 🤝 Fit with local context, values, and needs

Even if you hit the word count and answer everything, you’ll miss marks without these extra layers. This is especially important when tackling bid writing for home care services, where commissioners expect both compliance and strong evidence of practice.

💡 How we help improve your answers

When we review tenders, we’re not just checking grammar. We ask: would this give a commissioner confidence to award a contract?

That means:

  • 🔧 Strengthening your structure
  • 📈 Rewording for clarity and confidence
  • 🎯 Aligning answers with what the panel needs to see

Every change is about raising your score — not just polishing your prose. Our proofreading and review services combine polish with strategy to ensure your responses meet commissioner expectations.

📣 Ready to level up your answers?

We offer tender reviews that focus on scoring impact — not just language edits.

📞 Contact us here
Let’s make sure your answers say what commissioners need to hear.

📚 Catch up on the full Tender Review Series:

Written by Mike Harrison, Founder of Impact Guru Ltd — specialists in bid writing, strategy and developing specialist tools to support social care providers to prioritise workflow, win and retain more contracts.

⬅️ Return to Knowledge Hub Index

🔗 Useful Tender Resources

✍️ Service support:

🔍 Quality boost:

🎯 Build foundations: